Oooooooh, no.
That was my initial reaction to the selling of the University of Georgia’s president’s house on Prince Avenue. From 4,100 miles away in Edinburg, Scotland, I couldn’t believe what I was reading in 2023. The asking price would be an estimated $5 million.
I texted President Jere Morehead to express my concern and objection. He explained that it was the decision of the University System of Georgia Board of Regents and that he supported it.
I’m a fan and a friend of Jere Morehead. Still, the news stung. I wanted to know more.
The 1857 mansion is a showpiece. It’s also a money pit. The grand old “lady” is really showing her age. She needs multimillion-dollar electrical, HVAC and other upgrades. The Regents felt the money would be better invested in educating students.
As a former chairman of the Regents, I get that.
So, why did I get upset in the first place?
As a past president of UGA’s Alumni Association, I was echoing what thousands of other UGA alums also felt.
The first time I walked through the gate of that picket fence, I was smitten with the Grant-Hill-White-Bradshaw House. That was almost 60 years ago. President Fred C. Davison had invited student leaders for a backyard picnic. Every time since, I was flooded with memories as I crunched the pea-gravel path toward the towering steps to the veranda.
Since the 1960s, I’ve been fortunate to bond with UGA presidents Davison, Henry King Stanford, Charles Knapp, Michael Adams and Jere Morehead. My dad once joked that I’ve been involved in every campus organization except the Women’s Glee Club. And that meant a lot of visits to 570 Prince Ave.
I am grateful for every one of those experiences. And I am
especially appreciative of Chuck Knapp, who was president from 1987 to 1997.
Several times, he invited my boyhood friend Joe Phelps and his wife, Judy, to
join the pregame festivities. After a particular victory, Chuck said, “Joe, you
are a good-luck charm. When you are in the president’s box, the Dawgs are
undefeated. You are always welcome.” Joe left his wheelchair in 2018, but he
took that high praise to Heaven.
UGA presidents started living in the mansion the year after I was born, 1949. President Adams was the first to move to a private residence. President Morehead, coincidentally, purchased our former Five Points home from the person who had bought it from us. That means the stately house—with the magnificent front-yard gingko tree and white picket fence—is vacant.
Since that 2023 announcement, there’s been considerable moaning and speculation as to what will happen to 570 Prince Ave. Naturally, I am sad to see the tradition end. But it is time for a new chapter in the history of the Classic City’s architectural treasure.
So, what now?
Dr. Jeff Payne, a retired Gainesville eye surgeon, has a plan. With the Board of Regents’ approval, he will move forward with the purchase. Recently, we visited with Jeff and listened to his vision for the 5-acre property. He promises to preserve and protect the historical house, while creating a revenue stream that supports those goals.
The stately structure will be the centerpiece of a planned hotel and event venue. Low-rise construction will be in the expansive backyard, mostly unseen from Prince Avenue. His investment will be a windfall for the Clarke County tax digest.
I have known Jeff for almost 30 years. He is not a real estate novice. He has multiple holdings, including a hotel. One of his daughters, a UGA student, lives in a historic house in Athens. Jeff is not a faceless outsider.
Of course, I would have preferred more of the old days.
But today is today.
And Jeff has the knowledge, the passion and the wherewithal to follow through on what is very well the best possible outcome.
My “oh, no” is now an “oh, yes.”
dnesmith@cninewspapers.com